Nickey Huntsman and Lucas Frost are a kinky young couple with a competitive streak, and they both hate losing. After an intense masturbation race that Nickey Huntsman wins by squirting on Lucas Frost before he can cum, Lucas Frost goes on the prank warpath to get revenge. He's able to do so by covering Nickey Huntsman's towel in cum, and the sticky surprise, just when Nickey Huntsman thought she was all clean, evens the score. Back in the bedroom, Lucas Frost lies in wait in the closet, but when he sees that Nickey Huntsman returns frustrated, he decides to make amends by bursting out of the closet to eat her pussy. From there, make-up fucking ensues, although Nickey Huntsman has one more squirt-focused surprise up her sleeve.